Things Everyone Is Getting Wrong About Game Of Thrones

Comments

gardendaleguy's picture

this vid brings alot of decent logic...however, still doesnt compare to the reality that Jon and Dany got fucked with a 12 foot dildo...

+1
0
-1
Vote comment up/down
Bobbob's picture

Sometimes it takes a scottsman to help you see things straight.  Excellent vid!

+1
+1
-1
Vote comment up/down
sato's picture

starts out from a misconception. "absolutely and categorically" those 2 wrote the show, but based on everything already established in intricate detail by martin's books. where the books end is where creative license shoft over to the 2 show writers, hence why it's so different and so much worse.

 

it's not about what i or anybody wanted to happen, that's the problem. it was written from that perspective (what do we want the characters to do?) which is the entire problem. the things a characters do should come from their established traits.

 

why close the gate to north of the wall? plenty of wildings are settling south of the wall, they've made peace anyway, and there's a giant hole in the wall anyway. makes no sense.

where the fuck did arya's white horse go?

why would the north secede? the whole reason was they didn't want to be ruled by a southerner, and bran is a northerner.

make jon take the black? there is no night's watch anymore and there isn't a need for it anyway.

where did all those dothraki go? the unsullied left for naath, but nothing about the 4,000 dothraki who it turned out actually survived that charge at the army of the dead after all.

why would all those lords just accept that the north would secede without any argument and without then deciding to secede themselves and rule their own kingdoms?

and why the fuck would bronn ever be master of coin? not only would he be terrible at it and thus never chosen, he's said repeatedly the only thing he's interested in is living the rest of his years peacefully in a nice big castle. so what that just means he'll just forgo the giant castle he wanted and got and do some public service?

and arya? she was a passenger on a boat once so now she's a qualified captain and realizes all she's ever wanted to do was sail to new lands?

and now sam is a grand meister despite dropping out not even half way through his first course of study? sam would be the first to say no there are a ton of people who know a lot more than me. if you want i'll go study then return when i'm capable of actually filling the position.

 

give me a break. just brainfart writing the entire thing. people do things for reasons.

+1
0
-1
Vote comment up/down